Petition details
Petition to hold a referendum in Tower Hamlets to replace the ‘Directly Elected Mayor’ system after an informed debate so that residents and not just politicians have a say on the structure of how we should make decisions that affect us all
A referendum to establish a directly elected Mayor of Tower Hamlets with all Executive powers was held on the 6th May 2010 on the same day as national and local elections, it meant as a result that there was little time to debate the advantages or disadvantages of the Mayoral system, and no opportunity was provided to look at other options.
That referendum result can only be changed after ten years have passed, those ten years are now up and it is time to look again collectively about who makes decisions in Tower Hamlets in the future.
We believe that in the future we need a different system of government from that which has served us in the past. The challenges facing us are increasing in complexity, COVID threatens many parts of the economy of Tower Hamlets, the population continues to grow. This all makes it increasingly difficult for any one person however hard working to effectively cover everything with sufficient attention to detail and that therefore power and responsibility need to be more widely shared so as to ensure governance better suited to our future challenges.
In Tower Hamlets we could choose between four different types of
leadership and governance to achieve these objectives:
a. today we have a directly elected Mayor, where all executive
power and responsibility lies with one person, first Lutfur Rahman
and now John Biggs, Councillors have no powers in this model except
to ask questions (in planning and licensing committees they can
reject or accept officer recommendations);
b. a Leader and Cabinet, where a Councillor is elected as the
leader by other Councillors but otherwise executive power largely
remains in the hands of one person but Councillors (usually from
the largest party) choose who that person is, the model we used
before the year 2010 and was rejected in the 2010 referendum;
c. a Committee system (the most common system before the year 2000)
where power and responsibility is shared by Councillors in
different committees, now used by some London Councils, it creates
a more open and transparent decision-making process less reliant on
one person;
d. a hybrid model that combines elements usually of the Leader in
Cabinet model and the Committee structure, to ensure that not too
much power is held by one person and that there are more checks and
balances in the system.
Once a referendum is held, the result cannot be changed for
another ten years so it is important to get this right.
This Petition ran from 29/10/2020 to 23/12/2020 and has now finished.
21 people signed this Petition.
Council response
Thank you for your petition titled - Hold a Referendum in Tower
Hamlets to replace the ‘Directly Elected Mayor’ system
after an informed debate so that residents and not just politicians
have a say on the structure of how we should make decisions that
affect us all.
On 18 November 2020, Council resolved to hold a referendum on 6 May 2021 to give residents the choice of the ‘Directly Elected Mayor and a Cabinet System’ or a ‘Leader and Cabinet’ System. Minutes of the meeting and a copy of the report that was presented to Council on the day can be found in the following link below at point 10 of the Agenda.
http://democracy.towerhamlets.gov.uk/ieListDocuments.aspx?CId=309&MId=11602&Ver=4
Yours sincerely,
Monitoring Officer